Site visitors jams, heatwaves and hidden costs: you realize they’re coming however by some means they’re unattainable for the holiday-maker to dodge. This summer season, after on-line comparability purchasing, we paid an enormous sum for the privilege of gathering a rent automotive in Germany however dropping it off in Italy. Shock shock, once we reached the Avis workplace in Garmisch-Partenkirchen, they wouldn’t hand over the keys till we paid an additional payment. The issue was, they defined, that whereas we had paid to drop the automotive off in Italy we hadn’t paid the cost for driving in Italy. (Presumably, the net worth assumed that we’d wrap up the automotive in brown paper and ask Deutsche Publish and Publish Italiane to ship it to Bologna for us.)
The cost wasn’t non-compulsory, so why hadn’t it been talked about once we booked? My spouse’s blood began to boil. I began to chuckle and take notes for this column.
However wait; loyal readers may be feeling a way of déjà vu. Haven’t I described this actual state of affairs earlier than? Sure I’ve, again within the harmless days of 2019. The state of affairs was completely different, although. That was Europcar. This time it was Avis. Completely different firm, similar trick.
Why doesn’t competitors cast off such nonsense? One chance is that the forces of competitors are merely not robust sufficient: Garmisch-Partenkirchen is widespread with vacationers, however it’s not a giant place, and there aren’t that many worldwide automotive rent companies there competing for what you are promoting. A second chance is that we clients simply aren’t fairly savvy sufficient: the lure yawns in entrance of us, however we don’t watch our ft and we stumble in each time.
That second chance is an intriguing one. Everybody hates being ambushed by an additional payment, so why doesn’t a automotive rent agency win enterprise by proclaiming that they impose no hidden costs?
The reply, proposed twenty years in the past by the economists Xavier Gabaix and David Laibson, is that such a proclamation may backfire. What about clients who take a look at the hefty price ticket of the corporate that costs all the pieces upfront and assume to themselves, “If I can dodge the hidden costs I may be higher off with the competitor.”
Think about the traveller dealing with a alternative between Resort UpFront the place the room is dear however the cellphone, WiFi, minibar and parking are all sensibly priced, and Resort FlyTrap, the place the room is affordable to lure within the suckers who make pricey calls and drain the minibar. A reasonably savvy buyer may choose the all-inclusive Resort Upfront. A very savvy one will organize for a digital SIM, drop in on the native 7-Eleven to choose up a chilly beer and a few snacks, then keep in Resort FlyTrap, their low cost room subsidised by the suckers. In different phrases, “no hidden costs” additionally implies “in case you can keep away from hidden costs, you must select our rivals”.
The hidden costs can flourish, write Gabaix and Laibson, “even in extremely aggressive markets, even in markets with costless promoting”.
All that is annoying, and it raises the prospect of shoppers shopping for merchandise that they might not have chosen if that they had been informed the reality. My spouse and I had been wavering over taking the prepare to Italy and hiring a special automotive there; if Avis had listed all their charges up entrance, maybe that’s the alternative we’d have made.
And there’s a extra systemic downside, too. Even a buyer who spots each lure and jumps via each hoop might discover themselves paying an excessive amount of. It is because all of the obfuscation and misdirection weaken the inducement for any firm to supply an excellent worth. If solely a handful of shoppers are conscientious sufficient to determine the very best deal, they could discover that the very best deal wasn’t actually value determining anyway.
So what might be executed? One easy method is to insist on clear, all-inclusive pricing wherever possible. The UK’s Digital Markets Competitors and Shopper Act 2024 requires this, and new steering from the Competitors and Markets Authority would appear to explicitly forbid the car-hire firm observe of including a obligatory further native cost. (The CMA argues that even when a cost reminiscent of a vacationer tax is inevitably paid later and in native forex, it could and needs to be talked about on the time of reserving.)
These transparency guidelines are all very effectively so far as they go, however in an excellent world services can be bought with most comparability. I ought to be capable of ask a worth comparability web site or perhaps a digital agent to take my necessities, search the online, and return with the very best offers. This was the idea behind the “midata” initiative floated by the UK’s coalition authorities in 2011, which pushed for standardised, machine-readable phrases in banking, cell phone contracts, and vitality payments. The thought was that you may obtain details about your cellphone calls or electrical energy use, add that information into some form of comparability engine and be informed which supplier was greatest for you. Now we’re informed that AI brokers will begin navigating the online’s darkish patterns for us, defusing the booby traps and defanging the predators. I ponder about that.
Midata has been solely a partial success, making rather more progress in banking than vitality, however the extra advanced a product the tougher it’s to make smart comparisons. Every particular person has their very own sample of cellphone use or vitality consumption, however not less than these patterns differ in methods which are simple to match. However take extra idiosyncratic merchandise, or one-off purchases, and the complexities compound. The place and when did you wish to drive that automotive? How good a view would you like your theatre tickets to have, and would you want to incorporate drinks on the interval? We would like selection and selection, even customisation, however we additionally need trustworthy, comparable pricing. And as a fellow as soon as stated, you may’t at all times get what you need.
Maybe higher know-how and higher guidelines will forestall worth ambushes in future, however it’s extra seemingly that clients will discover themselves performing out a model of the serenity prayer, wishing for the savvy to identify the value traps that may be averted, the grace to just accept the value traps that can’t, and the knowledge to know the distinction. Failing that, “avoid the minibar” isn’t dangerous recommendation.
Written for and first revealed within the Monetary Occasions on 28 August 2025.
Loyal readers may get pleasure from How To Make The World Add Up.
“No one makes the statistics of on a regular basis life extra fascinating and gratifying than Tim Harford.”- Invoice Bryson
“This entertaining, engrossing guide concerning the energy of numbers, logic and real curiosity”- Maria Konnikova
I’ve arrange a storefront on Bookshop within the United States and the United Kingdom. Hyperlinks to Bookshop and Amazon might generate referral charges.